The fruit is very much like a hybrid of a Apple/Pear/Fig... Most closely resembling an Apple. I have looked up literally HUNDREDS of apples, and haven't found anything. Any help would be awesome!
That would be a Syzygium! It is related to Clove.
I would guess that it is Syzygium samarangense, or Syzygium aqueum or similar. My best guess is Syzygium aqueum, though.
Here is a source from the Purdue extension that will help: